Scottie's Eat-Mor

Just tried this hidden gem on a whim. It was a Tuesday afternoon around 11, not too busy! It has only counter seating, so if that is not for you, you may want to skip this one! They have street parking. The place is cute and well worn. They cook your food right in front of you and there are literally only 2 people working, the cook-his name was Randy was amazing made friendly. The server, I didn’t get her name, was great, not as friendly but had a sharp, sarcastic wit about her which I personally LOVE! Their prices were ridiculously cheap for the amount of food you get vi tried the Philly cheesesteak and not only was this thing huge, it was delicious! I also ordered my own order of fries, also a crazy amount, but they are literally cut and fried in front of you! They are unbelievable! My friend ordered a burger and fries, she was equally impressed with the fries and her burger was delicious!!! Seems like they get a lot of regulars and during peak times you may have to wait for a seat at the counter! The only negative, they only have one itty bitty bathroom and it definitely could use a cleaning, but as good as the food was not even mad about it!!! Oooh and they have a soft serve ice cream machine!

Scottie’s Eat More is the definition of a hidden gem! Tucked away off Main Street, this little diner is a must-visit for anyone who loves fresh made to order. The setup is classic—you sit at the bar and watch as your meal is made right in front of you. Everything is cooked fresh, and the care they put into it really shines through. The food? Absolutely delicious. Every bite is bursting with flavor, and you can tell they use top-notch ingredients. And the best part? It’s super affordable! You get amazing quality without breaking the bank. Scottie’s Eat More has that authentic, no-frills charm that’s hard to find these days. It’s cozy, unpretentious, and downright perfect. Whether you’re a local or just passing through, do yourself a favor and stop by. You won’t regret it!

This is my new favorite hidden gem. Reminds me, in a way, of my grandparents' kitchen. The food is great and the prices are so unbelievably cheap, it's unreal! The place is not big, it's a long counter you sit at, but you definitely won't be disappointed!!!!!!

Fantastic food at an awesome price in a fun diner atmosphere! It’s all counter seating and perfect if dining as a pair or with a small group. One gentlemen does all the cooking and service so expect to spend some time here but it’s worth the wait! Food is delicious and great portion sizes, I love the old school counter seating and ‘diner’ feel! Highly recommend this place!

The food was the best, I was telling the nice waitress (she helps run the place for her brother I believe), they should be number one breakfast establishment in Fort Atkinson. She was super nice, and the food was so delicious. It's so cheap to eat here and you get a bang for your buck. Please consider coming here.

I'm reluctant to review this place cuz I don't want everyone and their brother to find it. This is the best food on the planet served by the kindest folks that ever existed. Family of 4 with to-go boxes 34

My first time here . Stopped while I was in town for an errand. One person working , I assume the owner. He had it dialed in , taking orders , cooking , cashing out. Counter space only, food was good and very reasonable prices. This place is a throwback atmosphere for sure . Love these kind of places.

Tiny diner.... BIG portions!